A Practical Guide to Help Companies Keep Their Top Performers

Stop. Take a look around your office. Put on your judge’s robe and see if you can’t classify every single person into one of these three categories:

1. People who make things better

Few in number, these are the people in your company who have vision. They take what exists and improve it based on their ideas, talents, work ethic and determination.

2. People who keep things movin’

The bulk of your workforce, these people are dependable, positive contributors to the company. They develop solid plans to help the business meet goals or contribute to the successful execution of others’ plans.

3. People who make things worse

Similar in number to our first group, where they differ is that they occupy a disproportionate amount of time for those trying to move things forward. 1’s and 2’s often have to fix their mistakes or coach them repeatedly on how to fix their mistakes. They offer little in the way of new ideas and hinder implementation — actively or passively — of projects designed to move the company forward.

Let’s be clear: 1’s, 2’s and 3’s exist on every level of the company. 1’s aren’t necessarily your managers or executives, and 3’s aren’t necessarily your rank-and-file or less-skilled employees. I have worked with far too many 3 executives and been blessed to toil alongside a bunch of rank-and-file 1’s who made a difference.

Beyond that, your place in any group is not set when you get there. In my last stop, I was a 1 in my first year and, for a variety of truly interesting reasons, became a 3 (or, at best, a low 2) in my second. Ultimately, your movement in and out of these groups is your responsibilities, but there are outside factors that can play a part.

It’s important for a company and for department leaders to go through this exercise of putting the individuals on their roster into one of these three groups every six months or so, and certainly not less frequent than annually.

Unfortunately, some companies take this philosophy way too far and force people into groups based on pre-determined percentages, saying that a certain number of employees have to be a 1, a 2 or a 3 and following it up with, “The 3’s get fired.” That goes beyond silly into the land of the stupid. Every manager’s goal should be to hire a team of 1’s and to accept nothing less than a healthy mix of 1’s and 2’s at any given point during the year.

But this is about more than performance appraisals. It’s about what you as a leader are going to do with your most scarce resource and how your company should allocate its own most scarce resource.

Photo by Aphiwat chuangchoem on Pexels.com

Your Most Scarce Resource: Time

Please let’s not got into how leaders are sooooo busy. Effective leaders aren’t the ones who work 80-hour weeks. I have met plenty of great leaders who have a solid work/life balance and put in 40, 45, maybe 50 hours a week. It’s possible, and it needs to be emphasized for the overall health of leaders and the organization.

That said, however much time you’re willing to commit to the endeavors of your company is finite. Effective leaders divide that time up wisely. A system that identifies which employees make things better, which employees help keep things movin’ and which employees make things worse helps time management.

Leading 3’s: Don’t fall into the void

It’s obvious that the 3’s deserve the least of your time. Yes, 3’s should be given the opportunity to move up and out of that group, but that shouldn’t come at the expense of the other two groups. If you’re rubbing your headachy forehead because you’ve got to do another performance management meeting with a 3, you’re doing it wrong. Good performance management is a simple four-step process applicable to just about any individual, and it’s not a time-suck:

  1. Politely and professionally accentuate the areas that need improvement (while also accentuating the things they do well and can build upon. Everyone has something worth mentioning here).
  2. Work with them to develop a goal-oriented, agreed-upon improvement plan.
  3. Identify the available resources to help them meet the goals of that plan.
  4. Set them loose to sink or swim.

3’s with the potential to be 2’s or 1’s do not need more than one of these meetings in the course of a year — or the course of their career — to “get it.” But even 1’s sometimes veer off-course for a bit. And in reality, a 3’s problem might not be his lack of ability or her bad attitude. It might be you or the company. Either way, it’s best to quickly figure this out and for things to either improve or for both sides to go their own way.

Bottom line: Limit the amount of time you spend with 3’s. Not only can they be time-suckers, they also have a tendency to leave good leaders in bad moods. No, it shouldn’t be that way, but it happens to the best. Don’t spend so much time that you’re letting 3’s put you in a bad place for your other two groups.

Leading 2’s: Find your potential 1’s and work with them

The error would be thinking that the 1’s should get the most of your time. The reality is, most 1’s don’t want the most of your time — and they certainly don’t need it. In fact, great 1’s are often stifled by overbearing leadership that doesn’t recognize they just need to be free to do what they do.

More on 1’s in a minute.

The people to whom you should give the most of your most scarce resource are the 2’s. More specifically, your job is to identify the handful of people in the 2 group who have the potential to become 1’s with your support and encouragement.

So many good 2’s with the potential to be great 1’s end up leaving companies because management doesn’t recognize their potential and help them reach it. In fact, some 1’s become 2’s in practice when the company doesn’t do what’s right to honor their contributions. More on that in a moment, too.

Your success as a leader may ultimately come down to your ability to elevate 2’s and help them reach their potential. It certainly is something you can point out when you’re touting your own success story.

How can you identify 2’s with breakout potential? Look for the leaders without titles.

Managers are Common; Leaders are Rare

Here’s a working world truth: Just about anyone can become a manager, but only a small percentage of people can be effective leaders. Stick around a company long enough or apply for the right positions and show an ounce of charisma, and you’ll probably get an opportunity to be a manager. Suddenly, you’ll have actual…

Notice the folks who step up in various situations to handle things when managers or 1’s are not available. Again, this isn’t simply about being willing to work long hours. Often, the folks who put in the most hours aren’t good but rather are insecure and seek to make up for a lack of ability with time. Rather, this is about people who do more without having to work longer hours or being told to do it.

Find them. Nurture them.

Leading 1’s: Be the fullback

Leading a 1 is easy, fun and rewarding, for the most part. It can get prickly at times if the 1 lets her 1 status go to her head. We all need a little ego check from time-to-time. Provide that check judiciously and tactfully.

But outside of that, as a leader, let them do their thing and move the company forward while you share in the glory that comes their way. Your job is to be their fullback.

(Not a sports fan? Watch this to understand the reference: )

Clear the way for them to run. Keep office politics away from them. Make sure they don’t step on any hidden landmines. Give them what they need to excel. Cheer them on. Recognize their contributions. Fight for them and advocate them.

Which leads us to…

Your Company’s Most Scarce Resource: Money

Your company is not like you. While your most scarce resource is time, your company theoretically has unlimited time. Yes, a day has 24 hours for you and your company. But there’s only one you. If your company needs to devote more time to the operation, it can add people. Each person adds another eight hours (or more) to the company’s day.

But to add people, the company needs money. And no company can print money.

There are two ways companies can use its most scarce resource in pursuit of a better workforce. Unfortunately, many companies tend to ignore one. Worse, many are not good with how they administer the one they do remember.

1. Raises and bonuses

For the love of God, would good leaders please start using the system that exists to reward their 1’s? I fully understand that many companies allocate a fixed amount once a year to be spread across the employee base. Companies that don’t give leaders great flexibility with how they divide up the amount given to their departments are doing it wrong. Further, it is 100 percent not acceptable for leaders to shrug their shoulders and say, “That’s just how things are around here.”

Companies and leaders who are bad at rewarding 1’s with raises and bonuses lose those 1’s to companies that aren’t. Yes, it’s a nice theory to think stimulating work and kind words will keep good 1’s where they are. In truth, it might for a little while. But at the end of the day, stimulating work and kind words don’t help families pay bills and fund the things 1’s with good work/life balance want to do with their most scarce resource — free time.

So please… please … pay them. And don’t make them have to fight for it. Don’t make them have to make the case to you at the end of the year why they are 1’s and why they deserve more than the 3 percent the company has allocated. Nothing… nothing is as dispiriting to 1’s than to do what they do so well and then be lumped in with the others who don’t do what they do.

Again, let’s go back to who 1’s are:

1. People who make things better

Few in number, these are the people in your company who have vision. They take what exists and improve it based on their ideas, talents, work ethic and determination.

These are the folks who not only are bringing new successes to the company, they are making your life as a leader easier! Because of them, you have less worry and fewer things to do. If your friend did that for you, you’d take them out to dinner once in awhile, right?

Wise leaders of 1’s pre-emptively say, “Hey. I got your back. When raise time comes, I’m going to fight to get you XXXXX.” And then fight to get a commitment to get that X in place immediately! Many a manager has been left searching for a replacement for a 1 before raise time came around because they didn’t show their commitment to their top performers with actions, and not just words.

Also, if you’re a company with a multibillion dollar budget, how hard is it to find a little cash to reward your 1’s for showing exceptional initiative and performance? Why are you waiting around for the end of the year to spread some of the wealth they are bringing in at that very moment? Again, “That’s not the way we do things around here” is not an acceptable answer. Remember your role with 1’s: You’re the fullback. Clear the way through “That’s not the way we do things around here” and do things the right way instead.

What about 2’s and 3’s?

Let’s talk about 3’s first. It is disturbing how many 3’s get raises when the end of the year comes, second only to the number of 3’s who think they deserve a raise when the end of the year comes. If you’re not in a union shop where salary increases are mandatory if you’re breathing at the end of the year, why exactly are you rewarding people who are making things worse?

“Well, they’ve got a family. The least I can do is give them 1 or 2 percent.”

Great. And you’ve just done that at the expense of those who help keep your business going and those who actually make it better.

Listen, I get compassion. I would contend, however, that it is compassionate to help motivate people to search for a different job with another company that is a better match for their skillsets. No, I don’t think any leader should have a quick trigger finger when it comes to firing people. So a calm, rational explanation to an employee of why he is not going to receive a raise for the work done in the previous year is a good tool to send the proper message that the clock is ticking. I don’t care if you then give that person three months, six months, a year, two years to improve. That’s another matter entirely. What I do care about is that these 3’s are not a drain on the funds with which you can reward the 1’s and 2’s.

Speaking of those 2’s, not all 2’s are created equal. To reward all 2’s with the exact allocated percentage of a raise is wrong. You’ve taken the time to identify your potential 1’s. Tell them and show them! Let them know that, while the company average is a 3 percent raise, you’re giving them a 4 percent raise because, in the past year, they’ve shown greater abilities and the potential to bust through toward better things.

Talk about motivation! It’s the exact opposite of a good 2 being lumped in with all the other 2’s and told, “You’ve had a good year, but, in the end, you’re rated a 2 so …” You as a leader need to be better than that.

2. Equipment, Training and Travel

On top of not proactively rewarding 1’s and taking care of 2’s, many companies take an egalitarian approach when it comes to equipment, training and travel. This is a mistake.

Again, the key thing here is identifying your potential 1’s. Then, give them the stuff they need to fulfill their potential. Whether that’s a week at a great training program for future leaders or a new piece of technology that helps them be more efficient, pro-actively lead the charge to help them along. Sometimes all that separates a 2 from a 1 who brings in large amounts of revenue for your company is some new learning from a $1,000 seminar. Make the investment.

In addition, say “yes,” when your 1’s ask for things. Don’t make them write up justifications for the expense. If you’ve got a good 1, they know what they need to stay there. Be the fullback and help make it happen, even if you might not think the conference in, say, San Antonio is any better than the cheaper one in Toledo. No matter what, the one in San Antonio is better for your 1’s. Make it happen for them.

And if that means a 3 doesn’t get to go to a seminar that year or that her request for a new widget is delayed, so be it. Yes, you have to make sure you’re giving them what they need if they’re attempting to meet the goals set up to get them out of the 3 group, but just like with raises, don’t reward people who make things worse. Use those funds for the members of the other two groups.

Practice Right Now

So now that we’ve gone through all of this together, let’s return to the beginning. Stop. Take a look around your office or, if you’re virtual, think about the people who make up your company. Put on your judge’s robe and see if you can’t classify every single person into one of these three categories.

  1. People who make things better.
  2. People who keep things movin’.
  3. People who make things worse.

Even if you’re not a leader or manager right now, practice doing this. Should you ever find yourself in a role where you have an influence over the lives of other human beings, it’s a great system to help guide you in how you manage your most scarce resource — and your company’s.

More From ‘Ya Pay Peanuts, Ya Get Monkeys’

What Type of Bosses Do Employees Leave?

If you accept the truism that people don’t leave jobs, they leave bosses, the next question is obvious: “What do bosses do that cause their people to leave?” The answers to that are as varied as the types of…

Democracy and Newspapers

The three most influential people in my life as a journalist are, sadly, all part of the Great Newsroom in the Sky now. Professors Michael Perkins and Bob Woodward (AKA Bob Woodward-Not-That-Bob-Woodward) helped educate me at Drake University, and…

Why Your White-Collar Job Is In Jeopardy

Far be it from me — a guy who struggled to get through high school algebra — to suggest performance on standardized math tests is the barometer by which we should measure a nation’s educational system. Yet it is…

A Big Reason Your Workers Are Cranky About RTO

Here’s a workplace truth: Management often has no clue what the rank-and-file are thinking. This is often because employees suck at communicating directly, though their fear of doing so is often justified because of, shall we say, overzealous HR…

The Biggest Hiring Mistake Managers Make

I received a phone call from the CEO of the company for which I served as marketing director at about 6:30 p.m. on Valentine’s Day. I was waiting in the parking lot of a nice restaurant for my wife…

How Data Is Ruining Baseball (And How It Can Fix It, Too)

Smart businesses allow data to guide their marketing. The ability to do this is relatively new and likely not to last too much longer. A firehose stream of information is available on a company’s marketing campaign performance, its customers…

Your Car is Selling You Out

On the dashboard of my car is a tiny square, just a little bit bigger than a postage stamp, that is worse than my sister ever was. If I drive too fast, it tattles. If I brake too hard,…

Top 5 ‘Thank-Yous’ To The Bad Bosses Out There

Bad bosses shouldn’t be. Of course, I’ve never met anyone who self-identifies as a bad boss, yet we all know they’re out there, and yes, indeed, without a shadow of a doubt, they do suck. I’ve had more than…

The Most Important Work Lesson I’ve Learned

I’m not quite sure when I went from being the working world’s wide-eyed newbie to the grizzled veteran I see in the rearview mirror when I start the car for my evening commute home, yet here we are. I’ll…

WFH 4EVER? Not So Fast

It’s good to be the king.” Mel Brooks, History of the World: Part 1 I am currently sitting in an office that no one else wanted to fill. Two weeks ago, I started a new job with a company…

It’s a (Dysfunctional) Family Matter

Top 3 questions to ask yourself before going into business with relatives. My wife, Carla, is an amazing woman. She is exceedingly brilliant, the owner of a whole lot more A’s in school growing up than her future husband…

Why So Much Marketing Data Analysis is Wrong

Any idiot can gather data. In fact, idiots are gathering data all the time. Smart people are, too. So are ants and mosquitos. Every time I drive a car, I’m constantly gathering data. My brain is doing what human…

Onboard Matters: How To Get It Right

My elder son started an internship today at a company that makes stuff taste good. He’s a sciencey kid, very much like his mother, and will tell you the chemical name of the thing that makes something taste like…

The Hidden Art of Exiting a Job Gracefully

As a professional, I’m good at many things. I can churn out 500 really good words for a story or article on any topic very quickly. I can design an amazing social media ad or flyer. I can produce…

The Scourge of The Micromanager

Ask every single person whose job it is to manage other human beings and exactly none of them will self-report as a micromanager. Why exactly, then, do they seem to be so prevalent in the working world? No one…

Why Businesses Miss Out On Great Hires

I was talking with a business professional recently who was lamenting his company’s inability to hire and retain quality talent. People come in and are often highly touted, he said, but they either flame out or leave far sooner…

The One Thing That Makes a Coach ‘Good’

What makes a good coach? Interesting question, but it’s the wrong one. Oh, that question has all the right words. They’re just in the wrong order. If you want to talk about what makes a good coach, we can…

Top 3 Super-Secret Event Planning Tips

I have absolutely zero formal training when it comes to planning events. Before this became part of my job duties, I hadn’t planned so much as a birthday party for my child. Of course, I have zero formal training…

‘Go to HR?’ Are You Kidding?

Last week, a woman took to Twitter (because that’s what we do these days) to ask for advice on what to do following a male co-worker’s inappropriate sexually charged remarks, and ho-ly-crap did the Twitterverse jump all over that.…

It’s Not the Technology; It’s Us

It’s easy to say Facebook — sorry, Meta — is evil. They do such a good job of proving the point for us. They routinely violate their own privacy policies, they know what they do is bad for people…

3 Lessons for Employers From The Great Resignation

It appears as if The Great Resignation is going to stick around for awhile. More than 4.4 million people quit their jobs in September, amounting to 3% of the workforce. That beat the barely-had-time-to-take-its-coat-off record of 2.9% the month…

Seven Steps to the Dawn of Dystopia

🔻 What’s Below 🔻What shows our vulnerability 👨🏼‍🦳👨🏾‍🦳What step we’re currently on 🎈What the spark would be 💥 Ahhh, Dystopia, that imagined land where we watch zombies and Katniss and Mark Zuckerberg dance a creepy new form of the…

When the Popular Vote Doesn’t Matter in Marketing

⬇️ What’s Below ⬇️Marketing: Science or Art? 🔬🎨The nature of feelings 🤗😭😡How to measure success in marketing 📊 Here’s one thing that doesn’t impress me much as a marketing guy: The popular vote. This might seem crazy, considering the…

The BM Files – Goodwill/St. Louis Aquarium

Welcome to The Bad Marketing Files, the place where we look at marketing efforts ranging from the slightly off-message to the truly horrendous. The SettingA Goodwill/St. Louis Aquarium billboard on Interstate 70 The ProblemThe billboard sends messages neither entity…

The Two Business Principles That Govern Life

For as much as we try to complicated it with heady notions such as meaning, purpose and lasting significance, life essentially can be boiled down to two principles with roots in economics. Strip away all the not-unworthy teachings from…

One Simple Strategy to Boost Your Career

Website redesign projects suck. Anyone who has ever been a part of one will tell you that, and anyone who tells you it doesn’t suck is a liar or a masochist. I have been a part of four website…

Humble Hares Always Will Beat Arrogant Tortoises

The tale of the tortoise and the hare is one of the most misunderstood fables in literature, but it holds a great lesson for employees, businesses and business leaders. The story was written by evidently armless Greek fabulist Aesop,…

When Shouldn’t You Listen to Your New Co-Workers?

Remember that first night after Christmas when you were a kid? Your reward for being good all year (or, at least, being seen as less-than-horrible in December) sat right there beside you as the stars twinkled outside … that…

What This Site Is All About, As Told In 38 Gifs

So what exactly is going on here? Well, a lot. This website is various measures of creativity, therapy, safety, career exploration, vanity and insanity (plus a few mystery ingredients I haven’t quite identified yet) — all dumped into one…

Six Steps to Asking For a Raise Right

I freely admit I have a bit of a Joker problem. OK fine. Maybe it’s more than “a bit.” I am far from an educated film critic, but as far as I’m concerned, Heath Ledger’s portrayal of the infamous…

What To Do About Our Free Speech Problem

I have made a living off the First Amendment for three decades now, remarkable only in that it has not yet driven me fully insane. The first part of my career was spent as a print journalist and had…

Dealing With the Scourge of Workplace Negativity

I love free food at work. I don’t even have to particularly like the food being served. If it’s free, I’m happy. Not everyone shares this positivity. Every single place I’ve ever worked has nestled in its bosom at…

Three Ways to Make Performance Appraisals Less Horrible

Dave had about as good of a year as any first-year reporter at could ever have. I could spend paragraph after paragraph detailing all the ways he exceeded expectations, how he took the job description and obliterated it with…

Sharing My Story Via Podcast

When it comes to podcasts, I need a 12-step program. I counted this morning, and I regularly or semi-regularly keep up with 16 of them. There are dozen and dozens of more that had a limited run that I…

One Way to Know When to Start a Job Search

You’ve probably heard the theory that a frog placed in a pot of water that is ever-so-slowly heated to a boil will stay in said pot and die a blissfully ignorant death. This science experiment is often brought up…

Two Truths Hiring Managers Need to Hear

For prospective employees, Human Resources folks are the contact lenses of a company. Through these fine folks, a candidate is able to bring into focus what the company is all about, how it operates, what it values and what…

What it’s Really Like to Work in an Amazon Warehouse

Let me state this straight-away: I never peed in a bottle while I was working in an Amazon warehouse. That said, It doesn’t surprise me that some employees evidently have. Some background: I worked in an Amazon warehouse for…

When It’s OK To Be An Idiot

Human resources folks get giddy when you start a new job. Suddenly, their purpose in life is fulfilled — fresh meat to season with all the really important information that will ensure you have the best chance of success…

Let Your Storytellers Explore Their Multiple Personalities

One of the best parts of being a professional storyteller is that, if you find the right environments, you can explore the many different facets of your personality. And it’s a storyteller’s obligation to explore them, as well as…

Good Storytellers are Changed by Their Stories

Early this morning, as snow fell softly in the pre-dawn darkness outside and my family slept upstairs, I had a 45-minute conversation with a little boy who couldn’t understand a word I said and who said about only two…

Why Leaders Need to Involve Their Marketing Folks

There are many paths to the C Suite, fewer to the top spot and even fewer who reach that top spot with a even a fundamental understanding of how to “do” marketing. This can be infinitely frustrating to those…

The Boy Scouts are wrong: Preparation is overrated

Back in college at good old Drake University (JO 92… T-Ders will understand), I had some pretty fantastic journalism professors. There was, of course, the legendary Bob-Woodward-Not-That-Bob-Woodward, who, though he worked in Washington, D.C., during the Watergate era, did…

Two lessons from a really cool story

I am officially a Longhauler. Oh, I’m not sure that’s the actual term for it, but it’s the term I’m using to explain my membership in the oh-so-lucky club of people who are having often-debilitating COVID symptoms long after…

My Most Important Interview

I have interviewed hundreds of people during my career, everyone from professional athletes and presidential candidates to the woman promoting a charity bake sale. This past week, I interviewed my wife. Her dad — my amazing father-in-law — died…

The Insane Mr. Powers

His name was Fenton Powers, and my first impression of him was that he was insane. I was a newly minted middle schooler in suburban New York, reveling in the bigness of not only changing classrooms after an actual…

Patrick Ewing in a Jock Strap

When I was a wee-little storyteller of 17 years, I had the opportunity to go to the New York Knicks training camp to interview their rookie point guard, Greg Anthony. At 6’0″, I was able to look eye-to-eye with…

Mission: Operating Room

One day back when your storyteller was still Newspaper Guy, I was sitting in my office one late afternoon editing the work of my reporters for the next day’s paper. It was the end of April in Minnesota, which…

Telling the Tales of Torment

Shari’s message was one of five on my voicemail when I returned to the office after a COVID-inspired work-from-home quarantine. She told me she was one of our hospital’s first scoliosis patients 43 years ago, and, after seeing the…

Thing 1 and Thing 2 of Shriners Hospital St. Louis

When storytellers tell their stories, they don’t often beat you over the head with the lesson you should take away from their work. No author — be it of a 1,000-page novel or a 300-word article — says, “This…

Stuff You Learn From Doctors, Episode 1

Doctors are smart people. Those whom I have met during my first two weeks at Shriners Hospitals for Children — St. Louis have impressed me, yes, with their competency, but even more so with their passion and compassion. I…

The Jenga Kid

Sometimes stories just don’t work out. You can do all the right preparation, educate yourself on what is to be discussed, show up at the right time with all the right equipment and BAM! This story you knew had…

The Other Side of the Door

I stood in the hallway outside a patient exam room and took a deep breath. On the other side of that door was the first potential story of a new chapter in my life. It was odd. I have…

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: